Sign In

Our recommendations are made independently. We may receive commissions from purchases made via our links.

All-Clad Corded vs. Breville BSB510XL Control Grip Side-by-Side Comparison

By , , , and ·Updated

All Clad Corded

$119.95 from Amazon

Breville BSB510XL Control Grip

$129.95 from Amazon
All-Clad Corded vs. Breville BSB510XL Control Grip: Same Price, Different Power

Overall Verdict

Besides the pricing and the solid build with high-quality materials, there aren't a lot of similarities between these two immersion blenders. Everything from the size to the power to the style is entirely different. The All-Clad is bulkier and sports a higher-powered motor, while the Breville is more compact with a reasonable weight.

Regarding their testing performance, neither of them ranked high in our ratings since they all have their own shortcomings. Both were excellent at grinding soaked nuts but performed just averagely in the soup tests. Because the All-Clad is more powerful, it did a better job of liquifying frozen fruits, but the lack of an extra whisk attachment meant it couldn’t whip egg white and was even unable to make mayonnaise. 

Meanwhile, the Breville struggled considerably to churn out a serving of icy smoothie, but it did have the advantage over the All-Clad when it came to creating a stable emulsion or stiff peak, though the mayonnaise it produced wasn’t as creamy as others, if not very mediocre.

Ranking by
Showing: 2/2 Items

Pros & Cons

  • The heavy-duty motor is perfect for frozen fruit smoothies.
  • High-quality construction ensures great durability.
  • The handle is designed to be easy to grip and maneuver.
  • It performs with consistent efficiency.
  • It comes with extra accessories.
  • There are many innovative features like ergonomic pistol-like control grip with trigger operation.
  • Non-scratch base helps prevent scratching pots.
  • The whisk attachment brings more versatility.
  • The price is upscale but there is not much in return for its efficiency. 
  • It's just average at making pureéd soup.
  • Uneven acceleration causes an unpleasant blending experience. 
  • The hefty weight may cause hand fatigue.
  • The heavy blending performance is limited 
  • The blade housing base is relatively large, making it hard to fit well in certain blending containers.

Key Specs

Dimension
H17.5 x W2.8 inches
H16.5 x W2.9 inches
Weight
2.9 lbs (1.3 kg)
2.2 lbs (1.0 kg)
Number of speeds
8
15
Pulse/Turbo option
No
No
Min speed
7,776 RPM
6,014 RPM
Max speed
12,768 RPM
13,224 RPM

Where to Buy

Price at publication
$96.65
$113.48
$119.95 at Amazon
$129.95 at Amazon

*You help support Shouldit's product testing and reviews by purchasing from our retail partners.

Analysis and Test Results

Performance

Overall Performance Scoring
6.0
6.5

Hot Soup Purée

6.5
6.5
All Clad 10942212300 Immersion Hot Soup Purée Test
Scooping a spoon of pureéd soup from a full batch in a plastic beaker made by the All-Clad immersion blender.
A batch of soup pureéd by the All-Clad stainless steel immersion blender is checked for smoothness by being drained through a stainless steel mesh strainer.
Scooping a spoon of pureéd soup from its full batch in a plastic beaker made by the Breville immersion blender.
Scooping a spoon of pureéd soup from its full batch in a plastic beaker made by the Breville immersion blender.
A batch of soup pureéd by the Breville Control Grip immersion blender is checked for smoothness by being drained through a stainless steel mesh strainer.
Breville BSB510XL Control Grip Hot Soup Purée Test
Pureeing Time
30 seconds
30 secs
Result
Slightly Chunky
Smooth
Suction
Slight
Slight

Frozen Fruit Smoothie

8.3
5.8
All Clad 10942212300 Immersion Smoothie Test
A plastic beaker containing a batch of green smoothie whose parts are scooped with a stainless steel spoon is between the All-Clad’s motor body and a smartphone displaying the total blending time (1 minute and 13 seconds).
After finishing blending, the green smoothie made by the All-Clad blender was spread evenly throughout a white paper to check for solid chunks.
Breville BSB510XL Control Grip Immersion Blender Smoothie Test
A plastic beaker containing a batch of green smoothie whose parts are scooped with a stainless steel spoon is between the Breville’s motor body and a smartphone displaying the total blending time (2 minutes and 21 seconds).
After finishing blending, the green smoothie made by the Breville BSB510XL blender was spread evenly throughout a white paper to check for solid chunks.
Blending Time
1 min 13 secs
2 mins 21 secs
Result
Smooth
Smooth
Suction
Slight
Slightly

Mayonnaise

0.0
4.8
All Clad 10942212300 Immersion Mayonnaise Test
All Clad 10942212300 Immersion Blender Mayonnaise
Scooping a spoon of failed mayonnaise made by the All-Clad hand blender from its full batch in a plastic beaker which is standing between the All-Clad’s motor body and a smartphone displaying the total mixing time (2 minutes and 5 seconds).
Scooping a spoon of mayonnaise from its full batch made by the Breville blender and contained in a plastic beaker that stands between the Breville’s motor and a smartphone displaying the total mixing time ( 2 minutes and 39 seconds).
Scooping a spoon of mayonnaise from its full batch made by the Breville blender and contained in a plastic beaker that stands between the Breville’s motor and a smartphone displaying the total mixing time ( 2 minutes and 39 seconds).
Breville BSB510XL Control Grip Whipped Egg-Whites 1
Breville BSB510XL Control Grip Immersion Blender Mayonnaise Test
Emulsifying Time
N/A
2 mins 40 secs
Result
N/A
Quite Thin
Suction
N/A
No

Almond Milk

8.0
8.5
All Clad 10942212300 Immersion Almond Milk Test
A white plate of almond pulp being between the All-Clad’s motor body and a smartphone displaying the total grinding time (1 minute).
A white plate of almond pulp produced by the Breville stick blender being between the Breville’s motor body and a smartphone displaying the total grinding time (55 seconds).
A white plate of almond pulp produced by the Breville stick blender being between the Breville’s motor body and a smartphone displaying the total grinding time (55 seconds).
Breville BSB510XL Control Grip Immersion Blender Almond Milk Test
Grinding Time
1 min
56 secs
Result
Fine
Smooth
Suction
Tight
Tightly

Whipped Egg-Whites

0.0
10
All Clad 10942212300 Immersion Whipped Egg-Whites Test
All-Clad immersion blender review: a paper carton box, the All-Clad blending wand with its motor body attached, and a user’s manual lying side by side on a white table.
The plastic beaker containing testing beaten egg-white of the Breville immersion blender is put upside down on the white table with its motor body and a smartphone displaying the total whipping time (1 minute and 21 seconds) by its sides.
The plastic beaker containing testing beaten egg-white of the Breville immersion blender is put upside down on the white table with its motor body and a smartphone displaying the total whipping time (1 minute and 21 seconds) by its sides.
Looking at the beaten egg-white of the Breville Stick Blender contained inside a plastic beaker.
Breville BSB510XL Control Grip Immersion Blender Whipped Egg-Whites Test
Beating Time
N/A
1 min 21 sec
Result
N/A
Stiff
Suction
N/A
No

Design

Overall Design Scoring
9.1
8.7

In the Box

All-Clad immersion blender review: a paper carton box, the All-Clad blending wand with its motor body attached, and a user’s manual lying side by side on a white table.
A paper carton box, plastic beaker with lid, whisk attachment, blending wand with its motor body attached, chopper bowl with lid and stainless steel chopping blades, and user’s manuals of the Breville BSB510XL lying side by side on a white table.

Dimensions

The All-Clad immersion blender standing on top of its blending shaft on a gray table, with the length of the blending shaft being noted to the side as 9.4 inches, and the total length of the unit as 17.5 inches.
The Breville immersion blender standing on top of its blending shaft on a gray table, with the length of the blending shaft being noted to the side as 9.3 inches, and the total length of the unit as 16.5 inches.
Height
17.5" (44.5 cm)
16.5" (41.9 cm)
Width
2.8" (7.1 cm)
2.9" (7.4 cm)
Weight
2.9 lbs (1.3 kg)
2.2 lbs (1.0 kg)
Length
Shaft Length
9.4" (23.9 cm)
9.3" (23.6 cm)

Build Quality

9.5
9.0
A close-up of the build quality of the All-Clad’s motor body and immersion blending wand.
The whisk attachment, motor body, and blending shaft of the Breville BSB510XL lying on a white table.

Speed and Controls

A close-up of the All-Clad front interface which features a Turbo button, a power button, and a speed dial on top.
A close-up of the All-Clad front interface which features a Turbo button, a power button, and a speed dial on top.
A close-up of a speed dial on top of the All-Clad’s motor body.
A close-up of the Power button in the front interface and a speed dial on the top of the Breville’s motor body.
A close-up of the Power button in the front interface and a speed dial on the top of the Breville’s motor body.
A close-up of the Breville’s motor body, with a speed dial on its top and the power button in its front.
Activation
Press-button & speed knob
Press-button & speed dial
Min Speed
7,776 RPM
6.014 RPM
Max Speed
12,768 RPM
13.224 RPM
Presets
No
No
Noise Level
67 dB
76 dB
Digital Display
No
No
Pulse Mode
Yes
No

Blending Shaft

9.5
7.5
A close-up of the stainless steel blade assembly sporting 2 prongs of the All-Clad stick blender.
A close-up of the blade assembly featuring two stainless steel prongs of the Breville BSB510XL hand blender.
A close-up of the blade assembly featuring two stainless steel prongs of the Breville BSB510XL hand blender.
The Stainless Steel Blending Shaft of the Breville BSB510XL Control Grip Immersion Blender
Material
Stainless steel
Stainless steel
Type
Sharp Blade
Sharp blade
Guard Material
Stainless steel
Plastic
Blade Count
2
2
Removable
Yes
No
Dishwasher Safe
Yes
Yes

Beaker

0.0
10
The Breville’s 1250 ml plastic beaker standing on a white table with its lid attached.
Material
N/A
Plastic
Capacity
NaN fl oz (NaN ml)
40.0 fl oz (1.2 L)
Measurements
N/A
Yes
Weight
NaN oz (NaN g)
14.0 oz (397 g)
Height
NaN" (NaN cm)
7.0" (17.8 cm)
Dishwasher Safe
N/A
Yes
Tamper Included
N/A
No

Power Cord

10
10
The All-Clad Immersion Blender on a white table with its power cord that features a 2-prong plug rolled up next to it.
The Breville Immersion Blender on a white table with its power cord that features a 2-prong plug rolled up next to it.
Cord Length
5.1 ft (1.6 m)
6.3 ft (1.9 m)
Type
2-prong plug
2-prong plug
Detachable
 No
No

Extra Accessories

The Breville BSB510XL Whisk Attachment lying on a white table.
Material
N/A
Stainless steel
Dishwasher Safe
N/A
Yes
Removable
N/A
Yes

Usability

Overall Usability Scoring
8.0
7.8

Ease of Use

7.8
7.7

Handling

8.5
8.5
Someone is holding the All-Clad’s handle and pressing its button at the same time.
Someone is holding the All-Clad’s handle and pressing its button at the same time.
Someone is holding the All-Clad’s handle with one hand and rotating the speed dial located on the top of the motor body at the same time with the other hand.
Someone is holding the Breville’s immersion handle and at the same time pressing its power button, with one hand.

Blade Assembly

8.0
7.5

Cleanability

8.0
7.5